Guest Blogger Geoff Herbach, Author of Nothing Special

Felton Reinstein thought he had it all–a great girlfriend, an athletic scholarship in the bag, and football friends he could totally count on. Wrong  Like an elephant storming a house of cards, it all comes crashing down. And it’s Felton’s fault. Turns out his little brother has taken an impromptu road trip to Florida (aka desperate flight from all the talented people) to make a bid for stardom (aka fronting a hotel rock band with escapees from a retirement community). What’s a big brother to do but help pick up the pieces, even if it means giving up all the status, all the glory and once again facing a life of nothing special.

Book Boy Dream by Geoff Herbach

Stupid Fast has been out for almost a year. It’s been really great. I’ve traveled a bit, met lots of writers and librarians and bloggers. Best of all, though, I’ve met “elusive” teen boy readers – both through my blog, email and in person. Good stuff.

I do have some concerns, though.

A really smart 16-year-old from Brooklyn wrote to tell me how much he loved Stupid Fast. He also said, “I hate books, always have.” What? A freshman at a high school I visited the other day told me: “I only like two books. Stupid Fast and this other one I can’t remember.” Okay… I have had similar exchanges again and again in the last year. It reinforces the reason I wanted to write Stupid Fast in the first place: there is a good-sized subset of kids who don’t have enough books to read. I was that kind of kid.

When I was fourteen-years-old, I played sports and played in the orchestra, tried out for plays and did okay in school. On paper I looked like a normal kid, maybe even a pretty high achieving kid.

Here’s the truth, though: I was all crazy on the inside. I was all like: “I should shower again because… is there a weird smell? What are you looking at? I think Kerri and Audrey are laughing at me. I hate them! My shirt doesn’t fit. What’s that smell? I love Jenny. I love her. She hates me! What’s wrong with my shirt? There’s definitely something wrong with my ear. What are you looking at? What’s that weird smell?” ETC.

Crazy. But… here’s the truth: not abnormal.

Having taught writing to college kids for the last six years, I know something for a fact: Almost everyone (male or female) felt like a dork as a teen. They write essays about it. But, boy culture puts a premium on hiding the truth. The girls in my classes are better at expressing it. Many have read books for years that help them make sense of things. Boys, who need the help most, have very few books that address their concerns. A few years ago, my son decided fantasy no longer spoke to him, then he read a few books that did then stopped reading, because he could find nothing that spoke to him.

I had a similar experience. When I was fourteen, I read. A lot. If I hadn’t read Catcher in the Rye my life would’ve been much worse. Holden Caufield’s thoughts were so familiar to me. Even if they were a little terrifying, and he was on the edge, I knew that I wasn’t alone. I began to devour anything with a male protagonist. The more gritty, the more down to earth, the better (this was a big change, because up until that point, I pretty much read fantasy). Vision Quest, The Chocolate War, I am the Cheese, A Separate Peace… But soon, I ran out of material. I read some adult titles, but slowed down and almost stopped.

The publishing industry believes that boys don’t read, so they don’t publish books for them. My anecdotal evidence contradicts this belief to some extent. The boys I’m meeting enjoyed reading books that were meant for them, that directly address their way of thinking – which isn’t always pretty, but isn’t dumb or simple, either.

I’m on a mission, I guess. I want to write good stories aimed squarely at teen boys. In a decade, I want to have dudes come up to me and list ten books they love. The girls I’m meeting are able to do this! Girls are so lucky to have dozens of great books coming every month that speak to their experience.

If you’re a writer, maybe think about writing for boys? If you’re a reader, ask a librarian what’s new that speaks to boys. They’ll know (because there aren’t many titles). Maybe we’ll build a bigger market for these young men who need material so much!

Yeah, that’s my dream.

Blogger’s note: Do you think Geoff has a valid point? Is there a lack of material out there for teen boys? Do you have any recommendations?

Wee Wisconsin boy, Geoff Herbach wanted to play for the Green Bay Packers or join The Three Stooges.  His tight hamstrings left him only writing.  Now he teaches at Minnesota State, Mankato where he blows his students’ minds with tales of football and comedy glory, none of which are true. Visit


5 thoughts on “Guest Blogger Geoff Herbach, Author of Nothing Special

  1. The mindset seems to be that guys read Manga and play video games, while girls read books. I’m sure the market is right, to some extent. But I’m also sure that there are guys out there who like to read and are looking for more good books about guys. I tutor kids with dyslexia and there are many more males than females in that demographic. Finding good books to recommend gets harder the higher their reading level rises. There are still some great middle grade books for the male reader, but the YA field of authors who write for males have only a few (albeit bright) stars like John Green and Marcus Zusak.

  2. Wow what a really interesting post. I hated my teen years. Too many hormonal things going on…wish we could automatically be a grown up back then and I bet we’d have way less problems. Maybe. Of course, that also comes with its own sets of problems. Maybe I wish we were all born smart and we could just skip the teen/school years altogether. Anyway. I was frankly surprised teen boys are reading shallow person that I am but is there a limited amount of reading material for them…do you count Playboy? LOL, okay stop. As long as there are books like yours and they find out about them, that’s all they’ll need. ;o)

  3. My son is an avid reader and we search and find some great series. Most of the the series tend to be fantasy, mythical lands. They are reading one right now by Michael J. Sullivan the Ryria series that is wonderful! Ted Dekker has some great one as does Frank Peretti for the older boys

  4. Wish I could help you on that question, but I really haven’t been looking around for books that teenage boys might read. From my observations, it appears most YA books are for girls.

    Morgan Mandel

  5. As a tutor for kids with dyslexia (more males than females), I think video games and Manga attract guys. But there are a few good writers who are targeting young guys (John Green and Marcus Zusec for example). Good luck with this. I always like having more books to recommend to my high school tutorees!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s